New to Editing: Fundamentals – The Overlap Cut

Posted on: July 23, 2008
10 comments so far (is that a lot?)

In today’s world of whiz bang, high-tech, digital editing, the power of the lowly overlap cut has been all but lost in the tumult. I’m sure many of you have heard the term overlap, pre-lap or post-lap before, but you may not know exactly why one would use this technique when creating a sequence. Understanding this subtle, simple and effective tool, which editors pull from their bag of tricks every day, will make you a more seasoned and better editor.

Overlapping is used in editing most any kind of story. In it’s most basic definition it refers  to having non-aligned cut points for adjoining sound and picture tracks as highlighted in red above.  This would be distinguished from a “straight cut”, where all tracks have an aligned cut point, as demonstrated within in the yellow highlight.

The term originated in the days of editing celluloid film, when the editor would physically extend the sound or picture and have it “lap over” the incoming or outgoing corresponding frames. Now of course we do this virtually in our editing software’s timeline. Avid’s Media Composer is a bit more intuitive when it comes to allowing to do overlaps naturally, as the tracks are always treated as being “unlinked” (or double system for you old-timers). On the other hand when working in FCP, all picture and sound tracks are linked by default. However, linking and unlinking are easily invoked in Final Cut with the keyboard shortcut, Shift-L.

Sidenote: Avid-trained editors are bound to get tripped up at first by Linked Selection vs. Clip Linking. These are two different functions, which can and do work together, but if you’re ever at you’re wits end and just want to move a piece sound separately from a piece of picture invoke shift-L or Edit menu > check or uncheck the Linked Selection option (fig. 3).

The overlap cut has a variety of uses. I employ it often simply to smooth out the sound transition of a cut. For example, let’s say you have a dialog scene between two people. If the audio ambiances of the two camera angles are badly mismatched, straight cuts between the two can have a distracting effect, jarring you out of the scene. Overlapping, or in this case “pre-lapping” the dialog for each cut can help you hide the difference between the two ambiances. This is also known as “masking” the cut. Of course now, digitally, you can enhance this smoothing effect even more by adding small 2-6 frame audio dissolves (fig. 4) not to mention by adding additional ambiance (background) tracks. Filmmakers also use the overlap as a way to usher an audience more immediately into a new scene by placing some of its audio under the last few shots of the the scene that is ending or other non-sync shots from the next one.

Sound editors make wide use of overlapping when preparing dialog and sound effects tracks for a mix. Often the objective is to make the whole track seamless from beginning to end. Here sound designers and mixers work with pre and post-lapped tracks to make the audio environment they are creating a cohesive whole. Overlaps are used both as a means of smoothing dialog as mentioned above, and also as a way to change the nature or character of a transition. Crickets could inform your audience the story is transitioning to something quiet or calm. Thunder, laughter or crying would create other types of foreshadowing. Combine all of them, ad reverb and… well you get the idea.  Thoughtfully placing music so it leads us into a new scene, or has the scene remain with the audience after it has finished takes advantage of the cinematic effect of overlapping in much the same way.

In the broadest sense, creating picture and sound collages or montages is what editors do. Overlapping is an extension of the concept of montage. The overlap and other editorial techniques are designed to keep your audience immersed in the film experience and fully invested in your story.

10 Responses to “New to Editing: Fundamentals – The Overlap Cut”

  1. Steve Di Luzio Says:

    It’s often the simple things that can smooth out glitches that detract from your completed production.
    Great tip for a ALL editors…keep them coming!

  2. Loren Miller Says:

    Larry -

    Nice piece! Some comments.

    I would emphasize, the primary use of an L cut, as it is also called, should be for dramatic purpose, not simply dealing with mismatches. The proper way to deal with ambience mismatches is to *balance* and *mix* the audio tracks, not mush them together in prelaps or postlaps! Have a dramatic reason for using it. It can prefigure the location of an upcoming scene. It can be used to carry voice from a previous scene into a new location propelling the story forward. Depending on story needs, these are powerful tools.

    In Avid or FCP I use single frame dissolves to cover *sample* mismatches which would otherwise cause a click or pop. I don’t use L cuts.
    And ambience mismatches are *balanced*.

  3. Norman Hollyn Says:

    Great posting Larry.

    I almost never use little dissolves for sound smoothing, it’s so cluttered and makes it hard to shift something around. Instead I use the keyframing and rubber banding tool. No more difficult when you want to extend or shorten a piece of sound (especially music), but simple to slide in a timeline. Also, in my experience, sound editors will ignore rubber banding more easily than dissolves.

    I almost never make an audio cut in the same place as the video cut because I want to edit my sound on the first modulation of the incoming track. That will actually help to disguise any mismatched tone much better than all of the short dissolves in the world.

  4. Interesting links for August 11th | andydickinson.net Says:

    [...] New to Editing: Fundamentals – The Overlap Cut – A solit edit, a J-cut or an overlap. Doesn’t matter what you call it letting the sound lead the picture when you cut is one way to add polish to your edits. This great tutorial gives you the low-down (aimed at FCP people but some broad reference as well) [...]

  5. links for 2008-08-12 [delicious.com] | andydickinson.net Says:

    [...] New to Editing: Fundamentals – The Overlap Cut A split edit, a J-cut or an overlap. Doesn't matter what you call it letting the sound lead the picture when you cut is one way to add polish to your edits. This great tutorial gives you the low-down (aimed at FCP people but some broad reference as well) (tags: audio split video editing fcp) [...]

  6. Shooting and Editing with Final Cut Pro | News Videographer Says:

    [...] has a tutorial on the “Overlap Cut.” “Overlapping is used in editing most any kind of story. In it’s most basic [...]

  7. TeachJ Says:

    An “overlap cut” is also called a J-Cut or an L-Cut

  8. The Cutting Room: Week of August 25th, 2008 | Zoom In Online Says:

    [...] -How many of you are professional editors?  I’m going to assume not everybody is raising their hands, and further, I’m going to assume some of those not raising their hands will gladly accept any help they can get.  Well, HDFilmtools.com is here to help you out and you can begin by taking a look at their tutorial on the Overlap Cut. [...]

  9. Recent URLs tagged Editing - Urlrecorder Says:

    [...] recorded first by ZeroInfinity on 2008-09-17→ New to Editing: Fundamentals – The Overlap [...]

  10. Cool Links #23: Prime Time, Prime Number Post « TEACH J: For Teachers of Journalism And Media Says:

    [...] has a great use of nat sound.  But to someone new to video, you will also need to know more about L-Cuts and J-Cuts. This goes well with News Videographer’s post on Nat Sound.   Seems like nat soudn is [...]

Leave a Reply